Exploring racial equity in the science education journal review process

Science education study co-authored by Dr. Tara Nkrumah, Acting Executive Director, CGEST

Across a broad range of disciplines, research has found that inequity is systemic in the journal review process. Collectively, however, this study does not specifically examine racial inequity. Moreover, literature on the peer review process in science education, in particular, does not foreground equity as a subject of study. The present study aims to address this void by examining racial equity in the peer review process with a specific focus on journals in science education. Data are collected from lead editors of major science education journals through the form of interviews, focus groups, and critical arts‐based methods. The two research questions driving data collection are (a) In what ways does the science education journal peer review process promote racial equity? and (b) How are science education journal editors’ perceptions of racial inequity reflected in the peer review process? McNair and colleagues’ racial equity framework informs the explorations of journal review in science education from the lead editors’ perspectives. From our findings, we offer four suggestions for moving toward greater racial equity in the science education peer review process.

Read the article.

Nkrumah, T., & Mutegi, J. W. (2022). Exploring racial equity in the science education journal review process. Science Education, 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1002/sce.21719

This study is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. (2029956).